Should Christians Tithe?

Pastor Ryan Heathco6 min read

Maybe you grew up hearing that Christians have to give ten percent of their income to the church. Maybe you sat through a sermon where a preacher said anyone who didn’t tithe was robbing God, and it made you want to stay away from church for good. Or maybe you’re starting to follow Jesus, and you honestly want to know what He expects you to do with your money.

It’s a fair question, and sincere Christians who love the Bible answer it in different ways. I want to show you what the Bible says about the tithe, explain the main views fairly, and gently tell you what I think. Whatever you decide, nobody should ever pressure you or shame you into giving.

The word tithe means a tenth.

A tithe is ten percent of something. In the Old Testament, it was usually a tenth of crops, animals, or income given to God.

The first time we see it, Abraham gives a tenth of what he’d won in battle to a priest named Melchizedek (Genesis 14:20). Later, when God gave His law to Israel through Moses, He said a tenth of the crops and the flocks belonged to Him (Leviticus 27:30-32). Those tithes supported the Levites, the tribe that served at the Tabernacle and later the Temple and didn’t receive land of their own (Numbers 18:21). Another tithe paid for festival meals, and every third year a tithe was stored up to feed foreigners, orphans, and widows in town (Deuteronomy 14:22-29). Some Bible teachers add these together and believe Israel actually gave more than ten percent.

Near the end of the Old Testament, the prophet Malachi told the people they had been robbing God by holding back their tithes. God invited them to bring the full tithe into the storehouse and see whether He wouldn’t pour out a blessing on them (Malachi 3:8-10).

Christians read these passages in different ways.

Some Christians believe the tithe is still the standard for believers today. They point out that Abraham tithed hundreds of years before the law of Moses, so the practice seems older than the law. They also point to Matthew 23:23, where Jesus scolded religious leaders for carefully tithing tiny amounts of their garden herbs while ignoring justice, mercy, and faith. Jesus told them they should tithe and also do those more important things. For these believers, ten percent is the minimum, and generous people give beyond it.

Other Christians believe the tithe belonged to the law God gave Israel, tied to the Temple, the priests, and life in the land. They point out that the New Testament never tells Christians to give a set percentage. When Jesus spoke in Matthew 23, He was talking to people still living under the law, before His death and resurrection. For these believers, Christians are called to give generously and gladly from the heart, and for many people that will mean more than ten percent, while for some it might mean less.

People on each side take Scripture seriously. They love Jesus and they want to honor Him. This is one of those questions where believers can disagree and still worship side by side.

The New Testament teaches generous, planned, cheerful giving.

The longest teaching about giving in the New Testament is in 2 Corinthians 8 and 9, where Paul was collecting money for poor believers in Jerusalem. He asked the church in Corinth to finish the gift they had started and to give in proportion to what they had (2 Corinthians 8:11). Then he wrote:

“You must each decide in your heart how much to give. And don’t give reluctantly or in response to pressure. ‘For God loves a person who gives cheerfully.’”

2 Corinthians 9:7 (NLT)

In another letter to the same church, Paul told them to set aside a portion of their earnings on the first day of each week (1 Corinthians 16:2). Put together, these passages describe giving that’s regular and planned ahead of time. It’s based on what a person earns, it’s freely chosen, and it comes from a glad heart. Paul also said that God is able to provide for generous people so they’ll have what they need and plenty left to share (2 Corinthians 9:8-11).

I see the tithe as a helpful place to start.

As a pastor, I don’t believe the New Testament puts Christians under a rule that says you must give exactly ten percent. But I do think a tenth is a wise and helpful goal. It gave God’s people a clear way to put Him first with their money, and many Christians have found that giving the first tenth to God shapes their hearts toward trust. Some people will grow past ten percent over time, and that’s a joy.

If you’re giving nothing right now, I wouldn’t tell you to jump straight to ten percent tomorrow. Pray about it, look at your budget, and choose an amount you can give cheerfully. Then grow from there as God leads you. If you’re married, decide together.

A few cautions matter to me. Please don’t skip rent or groceries to give, and don’t borrow money to give. And be very careful with anyone who promises that if you give to them, God will make you rich. Paul said we shouldn’t give “in response to pressure,” and that includes guilt and big promises.

If you read these passages and come to a different conclusion than I have, that’s okay. Your standing with God doesn’t depend on a percentage. God doesn’t need your money. Giving is one way He teaches us to trust Him and to love other people.

God gave first, and He gave everything.

All Christian giving starts with what God gave us. Paul put it this way:

“You know the generous grace of our Lord Jesus Christ. Though he was rich, yet for your sakes he became poor, so that by his poverty he could make you rich.”

2 Corinthians 8:9 (NLT)

Jesus left heaven, lived among us, and gave His life on the cross to pay for our sins. Then He rose from the dead. He didn’t give a tenth of Himself. He gave all of it, for people who had turned away from Him. That’s the kind of love that changes a person from the inside.

You can receive that gift today. Admit to God that you’ve sinned and can’t fix it on your own. Believe that Jesus died for you and rose again. Choose to follow Him as your Lord. Baptism is where that new life begins, a picture of being buried with Jesus and raised to live for Him.

We’d love to have you visit Ben Davis Christian Church at 701 S. High School Rd in Indianapolis, close to Avon and Speedway. Sunday services are at 9:30 and 11 am, and nobody will ask you for money when you walk in. We offer Spanish translation every Sunday, Kids for birth through 3rd grade at both services, and a worship service just for preteens in 4th through 6th grade. Look for guest parking near the main entrance and stop by the café for coffee. Questions are always welcome at (317) 241-3944 or info@bdcc.org.

Jesus gave everything for you.