Why Does God Allow Suffering?

Pastor Ryan Heathco3 min read

When somebody you love gets a diagnosis you were praying against, “Why does God allow suffering?” stops being a question you can talk about from a distance. You may have prayed every day for things to go differently. You may still believe God can help and wonder why He hasn’t done what you asked.

The Bible gives us reasons to trust God in suffering. It rarely tells us why this particular thing happened to this particular person. If you’re hurting, there’s room to say how hard that is. You don’t have to clean up your question before you bring it to Him.

Why do bad things happen to good people?

Some suffering comes from choices people make. A person can lie, abuse power, or drive carelessly, and somebody else can bear the cost. Other losses are harder to trace. A body gets sick. A storm comes through. Sometimes the most honest thing a friend can say is that they don’t know why.

In the book of Job, Job’s friends are sure they can explain his suffering. If something this bad happened, they figure he must have done something to deserve it. They spend much of the book trying to persuade him. By the end, God tells those friends they haven’t spoken rightly about Him (Job 42:7). It’s possible to speak confidently about God and still be wrong about what someone’s pain means.

Jesus makes a similar point in John 9. His disciples want to know whose sin caused a man to be born blind. Jesus turns them away from blaming the man or his parents. Then He helps the man in front of Him. If you’re trying to know what to do for someone who’s hurting, that’s a good place to start.

What does Jesus do when people suffer?

When Lazarus dies, his sisters both tell Jesus their brother would still be alive if He’d been there. Jesus listens to them. When He sees Mary and the people with her crying, He goes with them to the tomb.

Then Jesus wept.

John 11:35 (NLT)

Jesus knows He’s going to raise Lazarus. He still cries. That matters if you’ve ever felt like trusting God was supposed to make you less sad.

Jesus also suffered Himself. He was betrayed, abandoned by friends, and crucified. Christians believe God used the cross to deal with sin and that Jesus’ resurrection began God’s answer to death. Revelation 21 looks ahead to the day God will wipe away tears and death will be gone. That promise gives us something to hope for while we’re still waiting for answers we may never get in this life.

If you have one thing to say to God today, say the part you’ve been holding back. You can tell Him you’re disappointed, afraid, or angry. Some of the Bible’s prayers begin right there. Is It Okay to Be Mad at God?