We know Jesus was Jewish, grew up in Nazareth, and lived in the first century. If you’re looking for his height, the color of his eyes, or how he wore his hair, the Gospels give us very little to go on. We’ve got four accounts of his life and no description that would help you pick him out of a lineup.
Historian Joan Taylor has looked at what we can reasonably infer from the people and place Jesus lived among. A Jewish man from that part of the world would likely have had dark hair, brown eyes, and a complexion typical of the eastern Mediterranean. That’s an educated estimate about a population. The portrait of a first-century man you may have seen online can give you a sense of the region. It can’t show you this particular man’s face.
Paintings of Jesus can tell you quite a bit about the place and time they were painted. A picture you grew up with may have been modeled on people who lived far from Nazareth, many centuries later. Remembering where Jesus actually grew up helps when you read the Gospels. He learned Israel’s Scriptures, went to the synagogue in his hometown, and celebrated Passover with his disciples. Those details belong to the life of a Jewish man in a real place and time.
Here’s one detail we do get. After the resurrection, Jesus shows Thomas his wounds. John could’ve told us all sorts of things about how Jesus looked that day. He tells us what Jesus wanted Thomas to see.
Put your finger here, and look at my hands. Put your hand into the wound in my side.
John 20:27 (NLT) · excerpt
Further reading
Joan Taylor on the appearance of Jesus, King’s College London