How Do I Forgive Myself?

Pastor Ryan Heathco6 min read

Some people can forgive almost anyone except themselves. Maybe you said yes to God’s forgiveness years ago, or you’d like to, but you still can’t stop replaying the night you drove drunk with your kids in the car, or the affair, or the years you were using while your children mostly raised themselves. Maybe it’s the cruel thing you said to your mom before she died, and you never got to take it back. Other people seem to have moved on. You haven’t. And every time you start to feel a little bit free, a voice inside says, “You don’t get to feel good after what you did.”

If that sounds like you, I want to help you think it through. The Bible doesn’t use the phrase “forgive yourself,” but it speaks right to what’s going on inside you, and it offers you something better than trying to talk yourself into feeling okay.

The real question is whether you believe God has forgiven you.

When we say we can’t forgive ourselves, we usually mean one of two things. Sometimes we mean we can’t believe God has really let it go. Other times we’ve made ourselves the judge and decided the punishment should last a while longer.

Both of those lead back to God. Every sin is first of all against Him, and He’s the one who gets to decide whether the debt is paid. John wrote these words to Christians who were still struggling with their own failures.

“But if we confess our sins to him, he is faithful and just to forgive us our sins and to cleanse us from all wickedness.”

1 John 1:9 (NLT)

Look at the two words John uses for God. Faithful means He keeps His promises. Just means He’s fair. And it would be unfair for God to keep punishing a sin that Jesus already paid for. So when you confess, your forgiveness rests on God’s character and on what Jesus did on the cross. It holds up on the days you feel it and on the days you don’t.

Guilt and shame do different things to you.

Guilt says, “I did something wrong.” That can be healthy, because it moves you toward God and toward making things right. Shame says, “I am something wrong.” It tells you that what you did is who you are, and it makes you want to hide from God and from everyone else.

Paul described two kinds of sorrow, and he was honest that only one of them helps.

“For the kind of sorrow God wants us to experience leads us away from sin and results in salvation. There’s no regret for that kind of sorrow. But worldly sorrow, which lacks repentance, results in spiritual death.”

2 Corinthians 7:10 (NLT)

The sorrow God gives does its work and then lets you go. It leads you to confess, to change, and to receive forgiveness. Worldly sorrow keeps you stuck in the same feeling for years and never takes you anywhere new. If your regret has turned into a daily punishment that doesn’t lead you closer to God, that’s a sign it has become shame.

John also wrote that even when our hearts condemn us, God is greater than our hearts and He knows everything (1 John 3:20). Your own heart can be wrong about you, and God knows more than it does.

Jesus has already taken away the sentence.

Paul knew what it was like to carry a terrible past. Before he followed Jesus, he hunted down Christians, dragged them to prison, and approved when they were killed. Years later he called himself the worst of sinners and said that Christ Jesus came into the world to save people exactly like him (1 Timothy 1:15). And he wrote this to Christians in Rome.

“So now there is no condemnation for those who belong to Christ Jesus.”

Romans 8:1 (NLT)

No condemnation means there’s nobody left who can rightly sentence you, and that includes you. If God has closed the case, you don’t have the authority to open it back up. Paul never pretended his past didn’t happen. He talked about forgetting what was behind him and pressing on toward what God had ahead (Philippians 3:13-14). He let God’s mercy describe him more than his worst years did.

A few practical steps can help you live like you’re forgiven.

Confess the sin to God specifically, and mean it. You don’t have to confess the same thing a thousand times for it to count. When the memory comes back, you can pray, “God, You’ve already forgiven that. Thank You.” Over time, that prayer can replace the replay.

Make it right where you can. If your sin hurt someone, and reaching out would be safe and wise, an honest apology or paying back what you took can bring real peace. Our post on how to ask someone to forgive you walks through how to do that well. Some things can’t be repaired, because the person has died or contact would only hurt them again. In those cases, you can bring it to God and trust Him with what you can’t fix.

Accept that some consequences may stay. A criminal record, a strained relationship with your adult kids, or a lost career may still be there after God forgives you. Living with a consequence doesn’t mean you’re living unforgiven.

Tell another believer. James says to confess our sins to each other and pray for each other so that we can be healed (James 5:16). Shame tends to get stronger the longer we keep it secret. Saying it out loud to a safe, mature Christian, and hearing them pray for you, can help you believe God’s forgiveness is real.

If a habit keeps dragging you back into the same guilt, you don’t have to fight it alone. Our recovery group, Re:Gen, gets together Mondays at 6 pm, and it’s full of people who know what it’s like to start over with Jesus.

And if guilt has you thinking that everyone would be better off without you, please reach out right now. Call or text 988 to reach the 988 Suicide & Crisis Lifeline, or chat at 988lifeline.org. Your life matters to God, and there are people ready to listen.

Jesus died for the very thing you can’t let go of.

Whatever you keep replaying, Jesus knew about it before you ever did it. He carried it to the cross anyway. He died for that night, that habit, and those words you wish you could take back, and He walked out of His tomb to prove the payment was enough. The Bible says that anyone who belongs to Christ becomes a new person, with the old life gone and a new one begun (2 Corinthians 5:17).

You can receive that today. Admit to God what you’ve done and that you need Him. Put your trust in Jesus, who died for your sin and came back to life. Then choose to follow Him, and take your first step by being baptized. You’ll still remember your past, but you won’t have to live under it anymore.

If you’d like a place to start fresh, we’d be glad to meet you at Ben Davis Christian Church. You’ll find us at 701 S. High School Rd in Indianapolis, a short drive from Avon and Speedway, on Sundays at 9:30 and 11 am. Spanish translation is available every Sunday; just grab a headset at the welcome desk. Bring your kids, too. Kids (birth through 3rd grade) have their own area during both services, and preteens in 4th through 6th grade worship together in a service made just for them. If you RSVP on our website, we’ll have a first-time gift ready for you. Questions? Call (317) 241-3944 or email info@bdcc.org.

God has not given up on you.

Sources