A scene in The Chosen may make you want to open the Bible and see what happened. When you do, you may find the event described differently or discover that a character’s story isn’t there at all.
Dallas Jenkins’ series combines events from the Gospels with imagined dialogue and backstories. It can help you picture the world Jesus lived in, as long as you keep that distinction in mind.
Many scenes draw from the Gospels.
One of the best things about The Chosen is how it shows Jesus as a real Jewish man living in a real Jewish world. Jenkins has said he wanted the show to be authentic to that setting. You see people keep the Sabbath and pray Jewish prayers. You see the weight of Roman rule pressing down on ordinary families.
Many of the big moments come right from the Gospels. The show portrays Jesus calling His disciples, healing a paralyzed man who was lowered through a roof, and talking with Nicodemus at night about being born again (John 3). It shows Him eating with tax collectors and sinners, which made the religious leaders angry (Mark 2:15–16).
The show also portrays Jesus as someone people wanted to be near. That fits the Gospel accounts of him welcoming children and caring for people who were often avoided. As with any portrayal, the details of the performance are the filmmakers’ interpretation.
Other scenes fill gaps with fiction.
The Gospels give us very few details about most of the people around Jesus. We don’t know much about the disciples’ personalities, their families, or their lives before they met Him. So the writers fill in those gaps with imagined backstory.
Luke tells us that Jesus cast seven demons out of Mary Magdalene (Luke 8:2). The Gospels also show her following Jesus and meeting Him after His resurrection (John 20:11–18). They give us little detail about her life before she met Him, so the series imagines that part of her story. It also gives Matthew traits the biblical account never describes and creates characters and dialogue to fill in gaps.
None of this is hidden. The show’s creators have said plainly that it isn’t a word-for-word retelling of Scripture. Many of the added scenes don’t contradict the Bible, but they go well beyond what it says. And because those scenes are acted so well, it’s easy to forget which parts are Scripture and which parts are someone’s best guess.
Let an episode lead you back to the Bible.
Jenkins himself has said the show should never take the place of the Bible. He’s encouraged viewers to study Scripture for themselves and to talk through their questions with a pastor or mentor. I agree with him.
After an episode, choose a scene and look for it in the Gospels. Read the surrounding chapter to understand its context. If you can’t find the scene, it may be an addition or a combination of passages. Mark is a useful place to begin if you’re new to reading the Bible.
John explained why he wrote his Gospel:
“But these are written so that you may continue to believe that Jesus is the Messiah, the Son of God, and that by believing in him you will have life by the power of his name.”
John 20:31 (NLT)
A show can make you curious about Jesus. Reading the Gospels helps you examine the accounts the series is drawing from.
The Gospels explain why Jesus died.
This new season focuses on the hardest day in the story. Jesus was betrayed by a friend, arrested at night, put on trial, beaten, and nailed to a cross. The disciples who had followed Him for years ran away in fear. Every one of those things is in the Gospels.
The Bible presents Jesus’ death as the way God deals with our sin. Jesus took our place on the cross and rose from the dead three days later. He offers forgiveness and a new life with God to those who trust him.
If you want to follow Jesus, you can turn to God for forgiveness and begin trusting him. Baptism is the first step in that new life, and we’d be glad to talk with you about it.
If The Chosen has made you want to know more about Jesus, be our guest at Ben Davis Christian Church. We meet Sundays at 9:30 and 11:00 a.m. at 701 S. High School Rd. on the west side of Indianapolis. Spanish translation and programs for kids from birth through 6th grade are available at both services.
Bring the question an episode left you with. We’d enjoy talking it through.
Sources
- Is ‘The Chosen’ Biblically Accurate? Examining the Bible and Creative License (ChurchLeaders)
- The Chosen and authenticity (Deseret News)