Yes—Jesus of Nazareth was a real person. Historians overwhelmingly agree that He lived in the first century and was crucified under Pontius Pilate. His existence is supported by early Christian writings and references from people who did not share the Christian faith.
That gives us a solid historical starting point. The debate is about how to understand Jesus, His teaching, and His followers’ claim that He rose from the dead. Here is what the non-Christian sources contribute and why they deserve attention.
A Roman historian who disliked Christians wrote about Jesus’ death.
Tacitus was one of Rome’s most respected historians. Around 116 A.D., he wrote a history of the Roman emperors called the Annals. In it he describes the great fire of Rome in 64 A.D., and how the emperor Nero blamed it on a group called Christians and had them tortured and killed.
Tacitus explains that the name Christian came from Christus, who was executed under Pontius Pilate during the reign of Tiberius (Annals 15.44). His description of Christianity as a harmful superstition makes his hostility clear. Even so, he treats Jesus’ execution as an event in history.
A Jewish historian mentioned Jesus twice.
Josephus was a Jewish leader who fought against Rome, was captured, and then wrote histories for a Roman audience. In his Antiquities of the Jews, written in the 90s A.D., he mentions Jesus in two places.
The shorter passage is about the death of a man named James, whom Josephus calls the brother of Jesus who was called Christ (Antiquities 20.200). He describes James being stoned in Jerusalem in the early 60s A.D. Very few scholars doubt that this line is genuine. It’s a passing comment in a story about the high priest, and it fits what Paul wrote about James, the brother of the Lord (Galatians 1:19).
The longer passage, in Book 18, describes Jesus as a wise man who did surprising works, was condemned by Pilate to be crucified, and had followers who didn’t give up on Him. Here I need to be careful and fair. The version we have today includes lines that sound like a Christian wrote them, such as calling Jesus the Messiah. Most scholars think Christian copyists added those lines later. But most also think Josephus wrote a shorter, original version that mentioned Jesus and His crucifixion under Pilate.
Two more Roman writers describe Christians and their worship.
Pliny the Younger was a Roman governor in Bithynia, in what is now northern Turkey. Around 111–112 A.D., he wrote a letter to the emperor Trajan asking what to do with Christians who were being brought to him (Letters 10.96). He describes people meeting on a set day before sunrise to sing a hymn to Christ as if He were a god. They also promised each other not to steal, cheat, or commit adultery. Pliny had some of them executed when they wouldn’t curse Christ. Trajan wrote back approving his approach.
Pliny doesn’t tell us much about the life of Jesus. What he shows us is that within about eighty years of the crucifixion, ordinary people far from Jerusalem were worshiping Jesus and were willing to die for Him.
Suetonius, another Roman writer, wrote biographies of the emperors around 121 A.D. He says Nero punished Christians, whom he calls followers of a new and harmful belief (Nero 16). He also says the emperor Claudius threw the Jews out of Rome because they kept causing trouble over someone named Chrestus (Claudius 25). Many scholars think “Chrestus” is a misspelling of Christ, and that the arguments were between Jews who believed in Jesus and Jews who didn’t. The Bible mentions that same expulsion in Acts 18:2, when Paul meets Aquila and Priscilla in Corinth. Scholars do debate what Suetonius meant by Chrestus, so I wouldn’t lean too hard on that one.
These accounts help explain historians’ agreement.
Put these together with the four Gospels and the letters of Paul, which were written within a few decades of Jesus’ life, and historians have more evidence for Jesus than for many famous people from that time. Bart Ehrman is a well-known New Testament scholar who is not a Christian. He has said plainly that Jesus certainly existed, and that nearly every qualified scholar of the ancient world agrees, whether they’re believers or not. The idea that Jesus never lived is seen as a fringe view among historians.
Most historians go further and agree on two events in His life. Jesus was baptized by John the Baptist, and He was crucified by the Romans under Pilate. Those two facts are about as certain as anything in ancient history gets.
Together, these sources give us strong reason to reject the idea that Jesus was an invented character. They place Him and the movement that followed Him in the world of first-century Roman history. The next step is to examine what the earliest Christian witnesses said about His identity and resurrection.
The bigger question is who Jesus is.
One day Jesus asked His closest friends what people were saying about Him. Some said He was a prophet. Then He asked who they thought He was, and Peter answered that He was the Messiah, the Son of the living God (Matthew 16:13–16). Jesus asks each of us the same question.
The followers who knew Him best said He died for our sins and then came back to life. Paul passed on what the first believers taught.
“Christ died for our sins, just as the Scriptures said. He was buried, and he was raised from the dead on the third day, just as the Scriptures said.”
1 Corinthians 15:3–4 (NLT)
Jesus died for our sins and rose from the dead. That is the message His first followers proclaimed, and it is the hope our church teaches today. Turn to God, put your trust in Jesus, and begin following Him. Baptism is the first step in that life of faith.
If you’d like to talk about Jesus, we’d be glad to meet you at Ben Davis Christian Church. Be our guest this Sunday at 9:30 or 11:00 a.m., at 701 S. High School Rd. on the west side of Indianapolis. Spanish translation and programs for kids from birth through 6th grade are available at both services.
Reading one of the Gospels is a good way to consider what you believe about him.
Sources
- Historical Jesus (Wikipedia)
- Christian Beginnings: Roman sources on Christians (California State University, Northridge)
- From the Archives: Pliny’s Letter to Emperor Trajan (Christian History Institute)
- 1 Corinthians 15:3–5 (NLT) (YouVersion)