Do I Need to Be Baptized Again?

Pastor Ryan Heathco4 min read

Maybe you were baptized as a baby. Maybe you chose baptism as a child but aren’t sure you understood it. Now you want to follow Jesus, and you’re wondering what your earlier baptism means.

Christians answer that question differently. At Ben Davis Christian Church, our practice is based on the New Testament accounts of people choosing baptism in response to faith. Your own story matters as you consider what to do next.

Baptism follows a decision to trust Jesus.

When we read about baptism in the New Testament, we see a clear pattern. People hear about Jesus, they believe in Him, they turn from their sin, and then they’re baptized. On the day the church began, Peter preached to a huge crowd in Jerusalem about Jesus’ death and rising from the dead. The people were deeply troubled and asked him what they should do. Peter told them:

“Each of you must repent of your sins and turn to God, and be baptized in the name of Jesus Christ for the forgiveness of your sins. Then you will receive the gift of the Holy Spirit.”

Acts 2:38 (NLT)

About three thousand people were baptized that day (Acts 2:41). Later in the book of Acts, an official from Ethiopia believed in Jesus and asked to be baptized right there by the road (Acts 8:36-38). A jailer in Philippi and his whole household heard the message about Jesus, believed, and were baptized that same night (Acts 16:31-34).

In each story, the people being baptized had heard about Jesus and chosen to trust Him. Baptism was their response.

Baptism is a picture of dying and rising with Jesus.

The New Testament word for baptize means to dip or plunge something under water. That’s why we practice baptism by immersion, where a person is lowered all the way under the water and then raised back up. Paul explained what that moment means:

“For we died and were buried with Christ by baptism. And just as Christ was raised from the dead by the glorious power of the Father, now we also may live new lives.”

Romans 6:4 (NLT)

When you go under the water, it’s a picture of your old life being buried with Jesus. When you come up out of the water, it’s a picture of Jesus raising you to a new life. Baptism is something God does in us as we trust Him, and it’s also a public way of saying that we belong to Jesus now.

Churches understand infant baptism differently.

Catholic, Lutheran, Methodist, and Presbyterian churches are among those that baptize infants. Their explanations differ, but they connect baptism with God’s grace and a child’s place in the community of faith. If you were baptized as a baby, we can respect that part of your story as we talk about what you believe now.

At Ben Davis, we practice believer’s baptism. We baptize people who understand the good news about Jesus and choose to follow him. If you were baptized as a baby and now trust Jesus for yourself, we would invite you to be baptized as a believer.

Consider what you understood when you were baptized.

Some people were baptized when they were older, but they weren’t really trusting Jesus at the time. Maybe they were pressured, or they did it to make someone happy. Others were baptized as believers and later drifted far from God, and now they’re coming back.

These situations are personal, and the right answer depends on your story. If you were baptized as a believer and you’ve wandered, you don’t need to be baptized again to come home to God. You can confess your sin and return to Him, and He’ll welcome you back. But if you look back and realize you didn’t believe in Jesus when you were baptized, it may be right to be baptized now as a true response of faith.

A conversation with a pastor can help. We’d like to hear your story and look at the Bible with you as you consider your next step.

The decision begins with following Jesus.

Baptism is connected to what Jesus has done for us. He died for our sins and rose from the dead so we could be forgiven and begin a new life with God.

If you’re ready to follow Jesus, you can turn to God for forgiveness and trust him with your life. We’d be glad to help you prepare for baptism and understand what it means.

Be our guest at Ben Davis Christian Church this Sunday at 9:30 or 11:00 a.m. We’re at 701 S. High School Rd. on the west side of Indianapolis, with Spanish translation and programs for kids from birth through 6th grade at both services. Let us know you’d like to talk about baptism, and we’ll help you connect with a pastor.

You don’t have to work through this question by yourself.